RETAINAGE HELD: $220,000. PROFIT EARNED: $110,000.
Retainage is a percentage of the contract and profit is a much smaller percentage of the contract, so on a thin margin trade the hold is larger than the earnings. Painting finishes last, which means it waits longest to collect the bigger of those two numbers.
A painting sub at $2.2M with 10 percent retainage has $220,000 in holds. Painting at $1M to $5M averages 5 percent net profit before taxes, so the year earns $110,000. The hold is twice the profit. Painting is the last trade on site, so its release waits on every other trade's punch list, commonly 90 to 150 days past substantial completion. The money is safe, and you can't use it.
Your GC is holding only what he agreed to hold. The schedule put you last, and the contract set the hold as a percentage of revenue.
This post covers one balance sheet line and the queue behind it. That page covers how painting operates and where the trade's margin goes across a year. Read CFO for Painting Contractors for the complete treatment, worked figures included.
WHY IS THE HOLD BIGGER THAN THE PROFIT?
They're percentages of two different things. Retainage is a percentage of the contract. Profit is a percentage of what's left of the contract after labor, material and overhead come out.
At 10 percent retainage and 5 percent net profit before taxes, the hold is double the earnings on every job you finish, in every market, forever. That's math. Better production won't change it.
Painting at $1M to $5M averages 5 percent net profit before taxes, tied for the thinnest of the trades SPM serves. So painting has the worst ratio of hold to profit, and it waits longest to collect.
WHAT BEING THE LAST TRADE MEANS.
In most sequences painting goes on after drywall, casework and flooring. Then it goes on again every time another trade damages a wall closing its own punch list. So the painter is on site the whole time everybody else is closing out the project.
Retainage releases at project closeout. Your own closeout doesn't count. Your work can be complete and accepted, and your money is still held while a mechanical contractor argues about a balancing report and a glazier waits on a replacement panel.
That's why 90 to 150 days past substantial completion is normal for a painting sub's final release. You did nothing to end up last in line. The line ends where the project ends.
WHAT $220,000 OF HOLDS DOES TO A $2.2M SHOP.
A painting contractor at $2.2M with 10 percent held across the book has $220,000 held in other people's accounts. The business earned $110,000 that year at painting's 5 percent net before taxes.
So twice the year's profit is receivable. Payroll goes out weekly, and paint is COD or 30 days. The money that would pay for both is in a retainage column. That's why a profitable painting sub borrows.
Put a number on the borrowing. $220,000 drawn on a line at 9 percent costs about $19,800 a year in interest. That's 18 percent of the year's net profit before taxes. You pay a bank 18 percent of your earnings to wait for money you already earned.
MOST SUBS MISS THIS: THE HOLD OUTLIVES THE JOB COST REPORT.
Send this part to your bookkeeper. When a job closes, most painting subs close the job. The cost codes stop, the final billing goes out, the job cost report prints a final margin and everybody moves on.
The retainage doesn't close. It stays on the balance sheet in one lump receivable, often with no job number. After eighteen months nobody can tell you which project the oldest $14,000 belongs to.
That's how retainage gets lost. Nobody disputes it. Everybody forgets it. If no one owns a hold and it has no follow up date, nobody follows up, and the GC's accounting department won't remind you. Keep a retainage receivable by job, with a release date and a contact at the general contractor. Review it monthly whether the job is closed or not.
THE THREE LINES THAT SHORTEN THE WAIT.
You don't need a lawyer for any of these. All three go in the subcontract before you sign it. Subs who know to ask for them do.
1. Retainage reduction at 50 percent completion. Many GCs will drop the hold from 10 percent to 5 for a sub with a clean record once half the work is in place. It's the most valuable sentence a painting sub can add, and most never ask for it.
2. Release when your own scope is accepted, so project closeout no longer holds it. If the GC says no, ask for an outside date: released no later than 60 days after your substantial completion regardless of project status.
3. Stored materials and mobilization billable on the first draw. It doesn't change the hold. It brings cash in sooner on a trade whose paint bill comes due before the first billing goes out.
The retainage reduction alone, on the $2.2M book above, moves $110,000 from receivable to cash. That's the year's profit in your account twelve months earlier.
WHAT IT IS WORTH TO ASK.
Painting averages 5 percent net before taxes against a 10 percent target, so a $2.2M shop is $110,000 short of where the trade should be. Retainage won't close all of that, and nobody should say it will.
It's the piece you can change without selling more work, hiring anybody or raising a single production rate. A reduction clause and a dated release are two sentences in a contract you're already signing.
The last trade on the job has the least say over the schedule. It has the most say when the subcontract is signed, because that's the one moment the GC needs something from you.
