BIDS SAID 10 PERCENT. 16.4 IS WHAT IT WAS.
A commercial general contractor doing $5M in tenant improvement buildouts priced every job with a 10 percent overhead rate. The trailing quarter said 16.4. Tenant improvement work is feast and famine, and the rate was set once and never adjusted with volume. Every bid left the office 6 points light before a crew mobilized. Whatever job started next paid for the shortfall. Net profit moved from 6.7 percent to 11.2 percent before taxes in 120 days. Most of that came from taking 4 points out of overhead.
The owner said it himself: he used income from new projects to finish and close projects already underway. That's how an underpriced backlog feels from the inside. Selling harder doesn't fix it. Each new job absorbs the last one's shortfall, so more volume makes it worse.
- Revenue
- $5M
- Before
- Bids using a 10 percent overhead rate against 16.4 percent actual, and net profit at 6.7 percent before taxes.
- After
- Net profit at 11.2 percent before taxes, mostly from taking 4 points out of overhead.
- Time
- 120 days from first call to an 11.2 percent net margin before taxes.
- Result
- A 4.5 point swing worth roughly $225,000 a year, and $389K a year of MCA payments stopped.
A $5M INTERIOR SUB. A TWO WEEK VIEW.
A commercial general contractor self performing tenant improvement buildouts. Revenue was $5M for the year, had moved between $3M and $8M, and a $9M year was projected. Cash was reactive, and he could see about two weeks ahead. If a job started trending tight, he found out after the damage was done, when he needed to know sixty days ahead.
EVERY JOB UNDERPRICED BEFORE MOBILISATION.
Three things were wrong at once, and each one made the others harder to see. Estimates missed some of the cost, so markup was also covering scope nobody had priced. Overhead went into bids at 10 percent while the trailing quarter was 16.4. And there was no job costing, so nothing reported the difference back.
Without job costing, one cost went unseen. Estimates charged project manager and superintendent time at roughly half of what those people cost the business. On a buildout, supervision is a large share of the work. Half is a big miss.
Slow collections turned a pricing problem into a cash problem. By the time we started, the business had two merchant cash advances. One was $4,200 a week and one was $14,200 a month.
AN ASSUMPTION THAT NEVER FLEXED.
The overhead rate explained most of it. 10 percent is the number contractors inherit. With level volume, an old rate is survivable because the error is small and constant. Tenant improvement work isn't level. Revenue moving between $3M and $8M spreads the same overhead dollars over different revenue every year. So a rate set once is wrong in a different direction every quarter.
16.4 percent was the real figure for the trailing quarter. Bids used 10. That 6.4 point difference is what the next job funded, and it explains the owner's own description of the business better than any cash flow statement did.
The estimating misses added to it. Supervision was priced at half cost. There was no line for financing material and subcontractors for thirty days before payment. Markup covered scope that should have been priced. Each of those makes the bid look competitive and the job lose money.
WHAT CHANGED, WEEK BY WEEK.
THE NUMBERS, NOT THE FEELING.
120 days from first call to a net margin of 11.2 percent before taxes, a change of 4.5 points worth roughly $225,000 a year at this volume. Most of it is the overhead cut, because that takes effect the month you make it. The rebuilt estimating template was not fully visible at the 120 day mark, since jobs bid under the old pricing were still working through the backlog. That gain is still coming.
DOES THIS SOUND FAMILIAR?
If this is you, you'll describe it the same way. New work pays to finish old work. You can see about two weeks ahead. The overhead in your bid is a number somebody picked years ago and nobody has recalculated. It's usually 10 percent, because that's the figure the industry repeats.
The tell is revenue that changes a lot. A contractor moving between $3M and $8M can't keep a fixed overhead percentage. The same overhead dollars divided by different revenue give a different rate every year. If your volume changes and your rate doesn't, your rate is wrong.
The second tell is supervision. Ask what a superintendent hour costs the business fully burdened, then ask what an estimate charges for it. If the second number is smaller, every bid with supervision in it is light by the difference.
See how CFOS applies to interior buildout subcontractors specifically on theCFO for Interior Contractors page, or book a 20 minute call. Josh won't pitch you or send a proposal.
