YOU KNOW WHAT IT BILLED. NOT WHAT IT EARNED.
Almost every subcontractor under $12M can tell you what a job invoiced and can't tell you what it made. The cost codes in the accounting system don't line up with how the work was estimated, so you can't compare the two. Job Profitability is the CFOS system that rebuilds job costing to match your estimating and reports cost to complete every month. You catch a losing job at 40 percent complete. Without it, you find out at closeout.
Job costing fails at this size for one reason. An estimator bids by assembly and crew production, a bookkeeper codes by vendor and expense type, and nobody translates between them. You get a profit and loss that's right for taxes and useless for managing work. It can tell you that you spent $412,000 on labor. It can't tell you which phase lost the money. When the cost codes match the estimate, every job tests your bidding. You fix a bad assumption on the next bid, before you repeat it for two years.
WHAT HAPPENS WITHOUT THIS SYSTEM.
Material makes money and labor loses it
A job can show a 30 percent margin on material and a negative margin on labor and still finish close to the bid, so nothing looks wrong. On the next job the mix changes slightly and the same crew productivity wipes out the whole margin. Owners see one good job and one bad job when both jobs had the same problem.
Overhead gets absorbed by accident
If overhead isn't loaded into the estimate at a rate that reflects your current volume, every job either absorbs too much of it or none of it. A slow month spikes your overhead percentage while a busy month conceals it, so a rate set 18 months ago is wrong in both directions. The result is a company with healthy gross profit on every job and no net profit at the end of the year.
The loss is discovered at closeout
Without a monthly cost to complete, the first reliable read on a job is the day it finishes, which is the one day nothing can be done. Change orders that were performed but never approved, quantities that went over, and productivity that never held all become visible at the same time. By then the money is spent and the argument with the general contractor is much harder to win.
WHAT OWNERS THINK IS WRONG. WHAT IS CAUSING IT.
What owners think: Owners conclude they bid the job too low, so they add points to the next bid and start losing work they used to win.
What's causing it: The bid is usually closer to right than the execution, and without job costing tied to the estimate there's no way to tell which one failed. A 3 percent labor productivity miss and a 3 percent bidding error look identical on a closeout report, and they call for opposite fixes. Raising the bid to cover an execution problem prices you out of the market while the execution problem continues.
WHAT THIS SYSTEM DELIVERS.
WHERE IT COSTS THE MOST.
Labor is the whole margin
On flatwork the material is a commodity. The money is made or lost on crew production per square foot. A crew 15 percent under the estimated rate turns a bid margin into a loss, and nobody notices until the pour count is done. Code labor to the phase, and you see it in week three.
Shop hours and field hours are different businesses
Fabrication and erection have separate production rates, separate risk, and separate margins, and most steel subs report them as one job. When the shop is efficient and the field goes over, the job still finishes near the bid and the erection problem follows into the next three jobs. Splitting the cost structure at that line is usually the single largest correction we make.
Change order work performed before it's priced
Electrical crews get asked for additional work daily and perform it to hold the schedule, and the cost is charged to the job whether or not a change order was written. Without cost coding at the phase level, that unbilled work is invisible until closeout, when it looks like poor productivity. Catching it monthly turns an unrecoverable loss into a billable change order.
THE OUTCOME IN PLAIN NUMBERS.
The first month of real cost to complete reporting is usually uncomfortable. It points at the two or three jobs that are underwater while they're still in progress. A job caught at 40 percent complete still has 60 percent of its cost left to manage. The fix is a change order conversation and a production correction, and you avoid a write off.
Over a full year the gains add up in the estimate. Every closed job sends a real production rate back into bidding. Your assumptions get tighter and your bids get more competitive, with less padding. The goal is your trade's CFOS net target before taxes at the company level, around the book's 12 percent rule of thumb. You get there by bidding from your own history.
