SAME REVENUE. SAME CREWS. $3.2M MORE IN VALUE.
A $13.1M marine general contractor wanted to sell, and the number wasn't there. It had four accounting staff and no job costing or reports by project. We built the job cost setup, cut spending nobody had looked at, and set up reporting on every job twice a month. Net profit went from 7 to 14 percent before taxes on the same revenue. The valuation went from $2.3M to $5.5M.
A buyer pays for profit you can prove and that's likely to continue. Proving it is a paperwork job as much as a performance job. This company already made more profit than its books could show. The $917,000 a year we recovered had been inside the business the whole time. Nine months of clean, documented profit moved the multiple from 2.5 times to 3 times. It also doubled the profit that multiple was applied to. The crews, the equipment and the work stayed the same.
- Revenue
- $13.1M
- Before
- Net profit at 7 percent before taxes, no job costing and no per project reporting. Valued at $2.3M.
- After
- Net profit at 14 percent before taxes on the same revenue. Valued at $5.5M.
- Time
- Nine months from first call to the revalued business.
- Result
- $3.2M more in what the business was worth, and $917K a year of margin recovered.
A $13.1M MARINE SUB. WORTH LESS THAN HE THOUGHT.
A marine general contractor doing $13.1M a year. The crews were experienced and the general contractor relationships were strong. The business wasn't in trouble, and the work kept coming. The owner wanted to sell. When he looked at what the company was worth, the number was well below what he had assumed. It had four accounting staff, and it didn't have job costing or reporting at the project level.
FOUR PEOPLE IN ACCOUNTING, NO PROJECT REPORTING.
The accounting team was staffed and busy. It closed the month, paid the bills and kept the record. Nothing it produced told anyone what a project earned. Adding people made the record more complete, and the business was no easier to read.
Nobody had ever looked at the spending. Subscriptions, vendor deals and material buying had added up over years of growth. Revenue kept covering them, so nobody had a reason to look. None of it was large by itself. Together it was most of a year's profit.
When a buyer asked the usual buyer questions, the answers weren't in a form anybody would underwrite. That set the price. The owner had assumed the size of the business set the price.
THE PROFIT WAS REAL, BUT THE BOOKS COULD NOT PROVE IT.
There was no job cost record. So nobody could tie overhead and spending to a job or question it. Net margin was well below what the trade supports, and the valuation multiple was applied to that low number. Every step was a paperwork failure. The operations were fine, which is why the recovery took nine months.
This page belongs under the Working Capital System. Valuation and bonding capacity are both underwritten off the same thing: a balance sheet and a profit record a third party will rely on. The Job Profitability System built the base under it, because a number for each project has to exist before anything above it can be documented.
WHAT CHANGED, WEEK BY WEEK.
THE NUMBERS, NOT THE FEELING.
At 7 percent net before taxes with messy books, the business was worth $2.3M at a 2.5 times multiple. At 14 percent net before taxes with nine months of documented profit, it was worth $5.5M at a 3 times multiple. Same revenue, same crews, same work. The business was worth $3.2M more.
Total time from first call to the new valuation: nine months. Most of the margin recovery was done in the first 90 days. The other six months built the documented record a buyer would rely on.
WHAT THIS DOES FOR A BONDING LIMIT.
A surety and a buyer underwrite the same two things. One is a balance sheet that can absorb a bad month. The other is a profit record clean enough to project forward. So this work reaches a bonding limit as well as a valuation. A limit increase wasn't the goal here, and we don't claim one for this client.
A surety reads three figures. Working capital as a percentage of annual revenue, with 10 to 15 percent as the range and 13 percent as the number to build toward. A current ratio between 1.3 and 2.0. And debt to equity below 1.0. If you want larger work and get the same limit at every renewal, the surety is almost always telling you something about those three numbers.
DOES THIS SOUND FAMILIAR?
Contractors in this spot are rarely in trouble, so it's easy to leave alone. Here's what to look for. You have accounting staff and still can't get a number for each project. Spending has added up over several growth years and nobody has gone through it. Your net margin is below what the trade supports. And you think the business is worth more than any document can show.
If you're a few years from selling, refinancing or asking a surety for a larger limit, the paperwork is worth more than the performance gain. Here, nine months of clean records changed the multiple. And the profit that multiple was applied to had doubled too.
See how CFOS applies to marine subcontractors specifically on theCFO for Marine Contractors page, or book a 20 minute call. Josh won't pitch you or send a proposal.
