$1.3M LESS REVENUE. MORE PROFIT.
A $4.9M concrete subcontractor felt that something was wrong. Revenue kept rising and the cash never followed. The books showed overhead at 5 percent when the real number was closer to 12, so every job had been priced against the wrong costs. We collected $203,000 in the first week, corrected the rate, and rebuilt job costing.
This is the problem we find most often, and the hardest one to see. Overhead was posted in places that kept it off the overhead line. So the rate in every bid was less than half the real number. The jobs looked healthy at the gross line and the company made almost nothing. Once the rate was corrected, every bid priced in the real cost of managing the business. The first result was turning down some work. The following year the company did $1.3M less revenue and made more money.
- Revenue
- $4.9M
- Before
- Overhead posted at 5 percent when the real number was closer to 12, so every job was priced against the wrong cost structure.
- After
- The corrected overhead rate in use in live bids. The following year, $1.3M less revenue and more profit than the peak year.
- Time
- About 10 weeks from first call to the corrected rate in use in live bids.
- Result
- $203,000 collected in the first week, and $130,000 in profit sharing paid for the first time.
A $4.9M CONCRETE SUB. REVENUE UP, CASH FLAT.
A concrete subcontractor doing $4.9M a year. It self performs flatwork and structural concrete for commercial general contractors. Revenue had grown for several years. The owner knew something was off and couldn't point to it. That was the most accurate diagnosis anybody gave us before we started.
GOOD JOBS, NO MONEY.
Each job looked fine when it closed. The gross margin was where the owner expected and the crews were producing, so nothing obvious needed a look. At the end of the year the company had very little to show for $4.9M of work.
Pricing came from the last similar job plus a feel for the market. The overhead rate in the estimate was too low, so the bids were competitive and nobody knew why. The company was paying part of its own overhead out of every job it won.
There was also $203,000 of overdue receivables that had aged with nobody following up. The owner had wanted to pay profit sharing for years and never could.
AN UNDERSTATED OVERHEAD RATE.
The books showed overhead at 5 percent of revenue. Rebuilt from the last twelve months, the real figure was closer to 12 percent. Costs that belonged in overhead had been coded into job costs and other accounts. For years every estimate had about 7 points less overhead than the business really spent.
A miscoded chart of accounts gave a low overhead rate. The low rate gave underpriced bids. Those bids gave a gross margin that looked normal and a net margin near zero. The Job Profitability System wasn't in place, and catching this is its job. You can't price work right when your costs are recorded wrong.
WHAT CHANGED, WEEK BY WEEK.
THE NUMBERS, NOT THE FEELING.
The following year the company took $1.3M less revenue and made more money than at its peak. The work it turned down was the work that had been losing money. The owner paid $130,000 in profit sharing for the first time.
Total time from first call to a corrected overhead rate in use in live bids: about 10 weeks. The revenue reduction and the profit increase both showed in the following full year.
DOES THIS SOUND FAMILIAR?
If this is you, you'll know the signs. Revenue has grown and the bank balance hasn't. Each job looks fine at the gross line, and the year ends with almost no net. Nobody has recalculated the overhead rate in the estimate for at least a year. And you win a suspiciously high share of what you bid.
Most owners read that last one as a strength. If you win most of your bids, you're usually the cheapest for a reason inside your own numbers.
See how CFOS applies to concrete subcontractors specifically on theCFO for Concrete Contractors page, or book a 20 minute call. Josh won't pitch you or send a proposal.
