CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027Join the waitlist: 12 months with no subscription fee
CASE STUDY · CIVIL AND EXCAVATING CONTRACTOR

FOUR MERCHANT CASH ADVANCES. THEN DEBT .

QUICK ANSWER

A $3.4M civil infrastructure and sitework subcontractor that self performs excavation and underground utility work grew fast and paid for the growth with four stacked merchant cash advances. Overhead was 32 percent and gross profit was 5 percent. We rebuilt job costing, cut overhead, and went after $245,000 of uncollected receivables. The advances were paid off, overhead dropped to 15 percent, and gross profit reached 33 percent.

This owner did what the market rewards. He won more work and grew, and the growth nearly ended the business. He took each merchant cash advance to cover a shortfall the last one created, until four of them drew daily from the operating account. Overhead rose to 32 percent of revenue while gross profit was 5 percent, so every added job made things worse. The work itself was fine. He was missing a job cost record that showed which jobs earned money, an overhead rate somebody had recalculated, and a collections routine on a schedule.

Revenue
$3.4M
Before
Four stacked merchant cash advances, overhead at 32 percent and gross profit at 5 percent.
After
The advances eliminated, overhead at 15 percent and gross profit at 33 percent.
Time
About 12 weeks from first call to the last merchant cash advance cleared.
Result
$245,000 of overdue receivables collected.
BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished June 2026Updated November 2026
THE SITUATION

A $3.4M CIVIL AND EXCAVATING SUB. GROWING AND DYING.

A civil infrastructure and sitework subcontractor doing $3.4M a year. It self performs excavation and underground utility work for regional general contractors. Revenue grew every year for three years. The crews were experienced and the customer relationships were solid. The owner paid lenders before he could pay himself. He said the business was busier than it had ever been, and closer to failing than it had ever been.

THE PROBLEM

PAYING LENDERS FIRST.

Every Monday he decided which of four lenders got paid and which vendor got told to wait. The advances drew automatically, so the money left before he could plan for it. With a daily draw, he could never make a decision from the account balance.

He couldn't tell which jobs made money. Some finished feeling good and some finished feeling terrible. The year end profit and loss was the only report on any of it. When a general contractor pushed back on a price, he had nothing to back up the number, so he cut it.

About $245,000 was in receivables nobody was calling about. His weeks went to covering the shortfall, and the money that caused it went uncollected.

WHAT WAS REALLY WRONG

THE PROBLEM WAS OVERHEAD AND COLLECTIONS.

Nobody had calculated the overhead rate, so bids were underpriced. Underpriced bids gave a thin gross margin. A thin gross margin led to borrowing against receivables that nobody collected on a schedule. He had treated each step as a separate problem, and every fix had been a financing decision.

Two systems weren't in place. The first was the Job Profitability System, because the job cost record couldn't compare a job to its bid. The second was the Cash Flow Cycle System, because nobody in the business was responsible for collecting on a set week. The merchant cash advances came from those two missing systems.

Job Profitability System
THE INTERVENTION

WHAT CHANGED, WEEK BY WEEK.

Week 1: Pulled the receivables aging and started collecting $245,000 of overdue invoices on a schedule, in order of which bill each one would pay.
Weeks 2 to 4: Rebuilt the job cost setup against his estimating assemblies, so he could see labor, material, and equipment by phase.
Month 2: Recalculated the overhead rate from a rolling twelve month average and cut the overhead that recalculation exposed, moving 32 percent toward 15.
Months 2 to 3: Paid down and paid off the merchant cash advances in order of effective rate, out of collections, with no new borrowing.
THE OUTCOME

THE NUMBERS, NOT THE FEELING.

$245K
Overdue Receivables Collected
4 to 0
Merchant Cash Advances (MCAs)
32 to 15%
Overhead Rate
5 to 33%
Gross Profit

Gross profit moved from 5 percent to 33 percent without raising a single bid, once job costing was rebuilt. Overhead came down from 32 percent to 15 percent on its own line. The business is now debt free.

Total time from first call to the last merchant cash advance being cleared: about 12 weeks. The overhead reduction and the gross profit correction held through the following year.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR OTHER CONTRACTORS

DOES THIS SOUND FAMILIAR?

If you're in this spot, four things are probably true. Revenue has grown every year and the bank balance hasn't. You took at least one financing product to cover a shortfall, and it didn't buy an asset. Nobody can say which of your last five jobs earned the most. And your receivables aging has invoices on it that everyone stopped bringing up.

If two or more of those describe your business, it's very likely the same chain. The order of the fix counts for more than the size of it.

See how CFOS applies to civil and excavating subcontractors specifically on theCFO for Civil and Excavating Contractors page, or book a 20 minute call. Josh won't pitch you or send a proposal.

COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

Because nobody had calculated the overhead rate, so bids were underpriced. The thin gross margin left a cash shortfall, and he covered each one with financing. The Job Profitability System wasn't in place, so no job could be compared to its bid. The Cash Flow Cycle System wasn't in place either, so $245,000 of receivables aged while the owner borrowed against the same work.

Four merchant cash advances eliminated, $245,000 of overdue receivables pursued systematically, overhead reduced from 32 percent to 15 percent of revenue, and gross profit moved from 5 percent to 33 percent. The advances were cleared in about 12 weeks from the first call, and the business is now debt free.

Yes, for civil, sitework, excavating and underground utility subcontractors between about $1M and $12M where the work is good and the money side isn't. The order counts. Collect first, because it costs nothing. Rebuild job costing second, so bids stop repeating the same error. Fix overhead third. Pay off the financing last, out of the cash the first three bring in. Most attempts fail because they do it in reverse order.
WHAT THIS TIES INTO
Josh Luebker, SPM The Construction CFO
Josh Luebker
FRACTIONAL CFO · SPM THE CONSTRUCTION CFO

Josh Luebker is a master electrician turned construction CFO, president of SPM The Construction CFO and author of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

IS YOUR FINANCING COVERING A SHORTFALL OR BUYING AN ASSET?

Twenty minutes of questions about what the financing was for, what it costs you each month, and what your receivables look like next to it. We don't sell or propose anything. If Josh can help, you'll set a longer call.

You don't hire a CFO because it's safe, you do it because the real risk isn't having one.
Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. No pitch or proposal. Josh asks questions to find out if he can help.

OR START WITH THE WORKBOOKS. NO CALL NEEDED.