CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027Join the waitlist: 12 months with no subscription fee
CASE STUDY · SWPPP CONTRACTOR

$24,000 IN NET PROFIT. THEN $1.1 MILLION.

QUICK ANSWER

An erosion control and SWPPP contractor was doing $5.2M and netting $24,000 before taxes. Nobody tracked sites one by one, so nobody knew which ones made money and which ones used up what the others made. We built job costing for each site, fixed the overhead rate, and added WIP reporting. Net profit reached $1.1M before taxes the following year.

A SWPPP and erosion control business has dozens of sites at once. Each has its own inspection schedule, material use and crew travel. Each one is too small to seem worth its own report. That's why this trade is so exposed. Averaged together, the sites looked like a company near break even. The average covered up a wide spread, where a handful of sites paid for the rest. Giving every site its own number was the whole fix. It worked because the profitable work was already there.

Revenue
$5.2M
Before
$5.2M of revenue and $24,000 of net profit before taxes, with sites not tracked individually.
After
Per site reporting in place every month. Net profit of $1,105,000 before taxes in 2025, a 30 percent net margin before taxes, on $1.6M less revenue than the peak year.
Time
About 10 weeks to per site reporting. The full profit result showed in the following complete year.
Result
Net profit from $24,000 to $1.1M before taxes.
BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished June 2026Updated November 2026
THE SITUATION

A $5.2M SWPPP SUB. FIFTY SITES, ONE NUMBER.

An erosion control and SWPPP contractor doing $5.2M a year. It handles inspection, installation and maintenance across a large number of active sites for civil general contractors and developers. The crews were experienced and the customer base was strong, so work was never the problem. The company netted $24,000 before taxes on $5.2M, which is close to nothing for a business that size.

THE PROBLEM

NO IDEA WHICH SITES PAID.

Every site was billed and costed into one pool. The company knew what it made in total and nothing about where. A site with long crew travel and heavy maintenance looked the same in the books as a site 10 minutes away that needed almost nothing.

Pricing was the same for all of them. So the sites that cost a lot to service were priced like cheap ones. Nobody turned down or repriced anything, because nothing told them to.

Overhead was posted at a rate nobody had recalculated for the current volume. So the one pooled number they had was wrong twice.

WHAT WAS REALLY WRONG

POOLED COSTING CONCEALING THE SPREAD.

Job costs were pooled for the whole company. So pricing couldn't reflect what it cost to serve each site. Profitable sites paid for unprofitable ones. Net margin was near zero at a revenue level that should have made real money.

The Job Profitability System wasn't in place, and this is the clearest way it fails. You can't manage service work spread over many sites on an average. The average is the one number sure to describe none of the sites.

Job Profitability System
THE INTERVENTION

WHAT CHANGED, WEEK BY WEEK.

Week 1: Split the existing cost data by site as far as the records allowed, which produced the first view of the spread between best and worst.
Weeks 2 to 4: Built per site job costing so crew time, travel, and material posted against the site that consumed them from that point forward.
Month 2: Recalculated the overhead rate against current volume and loaded a real cost to serve into pricing for each site type.
Months 2 to 3: Added monthly WIP reporting so every site had its own number. Repricing or dropping a site became a routine decision.
THE OUTCOME

THE NUMBERS, NOT THE FEELING.

$24K to $1.1M
Net Profit, $1.1M After Taxes
$1,105,000
Net Profit After Taxes, 2025
30%
Net Margin Before Taxes
$1.6M
Less Revenue Than Peak Year

In 2025 the company netted $1,105,000 before taxes, a 30 percent net margin, on $1.6M less revenue than its peak year. The revenue it gave up had been using up the profit from everything else.

Total time from first call to per site reporting in place every month: about 10 weeks. The full profit result showed in the following complete year.

WHERE THEY ARE NOW · AUGUST 2026

SIXTEEN MONTHS LATER. EQUITY UP $1.17M.

$475K to $1.65M equity, April 2025 to August 2026.
3.32 to 0.92 debt to equity, April 2025 to August 2026.
Negative $90K to $1.07M working capital, April 2025 to August 2026.
0.92 to 2.12 current ratio, April 2025 to August 2026.

The profit from 2025 stayed in the business. From April 2025 to August 2026, equity went from $475K to $1.65M, working capital from negative $90K to $1.07M, debt to equity from 3.32 to 0.92, and the current ratio from 0.92 to 2.12.

2026 has been a lighter year for new work so far. Revenue through August was $1.32M, against $2.23M for the same eight months of 2025, and the year to date is a loss of $48K before taxes. For most stormwater contractors, a slow year turns into a cash problem.

Here it did not. In every month of 2026, working capital stayed above $510K and the current ratio stayed at 1.49 or better. Per site job costing shows which sites still earn at the lower volume, and the balance sheet built in 2025 pays for the slow months while new work comes in.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR OTHER CONTRACTORS

DOES THIS SOUND FAMILIAR?

This applies to any contractor with many small jobs or sites at once. Here's what to look for. Costs are pooled because no single site seems big enough to track. Pricing is about the same across very different sites. Revenue is fine and net profit isn't. And nobody can point to your worst site.

If you can't point to your worst three sites without looking, your average is covering up the same spread it covered up here.

See how CFOS applies to SWPPP subcontractors specifically on theCFO for SWPPP Contractors page, or book a 20 minute call. Josh won't pitch you or send a proposal.

COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

Job costs were pooled for the whole company and nobody tracked them by site. So pricing couldn't reflect the cost to serve each site, and profitable sites paid for unprofitable ones. The Job Profitability System wasn't in place. You can't manage service work across many sites on an average, because the average is the one number that describes none of the sites.

Net profit went from $24,000 to $1.1M before taxes the following year. In 2025 the company netted $1,105,000 before taxes, a 30 percent net margin, on $1.6M less revenue than its peak year. Per site reporting was in place monthly in about 10 weeks, and the full profit result showed in the next complete year.

Yes, and it applies to SWPPP, erosion control, and any environmental or inspection service contractor roughly between $1M and $12M that has many small sites at once. The trade is the most exposed to this failure because no single site is large enough to justify its own report, which is why pooling feels reasonable and costs the most.
WHAT THIS TIES INTO
Josh Luebker, SPM The Construction CFO
Josh Luebker
FRACTIONAL CFO · SPM THE CONSTRUCTION CFO

Josh Luebker is a master electrician turned construction CFO, president of SPM The Construction CFO and author of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

CAN YOU POINT AT YOUR WORST THREE SITES?

Twenty minutes of questions about your active sites, how each one gets costed, and whether you can see the spread between the best and the worst. Nothing gets sold and nothing gets proposed. If Josh can help, you'll set a longer call.

You don't hire a CFO because it's safe, you do it because the real risk isn't having one.
Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. No pitch or proposal. Josh asks questions to find out if he can help.

OR START WITH THE WORKBOOKS. NO CALL NEEDED.