RETHINKING YOUR CPA? MOST SUBS KEEP THEM AND ADD A LAYER.
A traditional CPA looks backward. Tax returns, compliance and year end. That work still has to get done. For most subcontractors the answer is to keep the CPA and add the work the CPA doesn't do: the monthly close, job costing and decisions about what's next. The alternatives are a construction-focused CPA firm, an outsourced CFO alongside your CPA, or an in-house hire.
It comes down to timing. A CPA firm works on the past, usually after the year ends. Construction finance happens inside the month. Is this job making money? What is over billing doing to your cash? What does next quarter look like? If you rely on a CPA alone, you usually get accurate tax returns and no answer to which jobs earn. That's a different job from the one CPAs do. So decide which parts of the finance work your CPA keeps, and which go to someone who is in your numbers every month.
WHAT EACH ONE DOES.
| Capability | Keep the traditional CPA | A construction-focused CPA firm | An outsourced CFO alongside your CPA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time direction | Backward, the year just ended | Backward, with more construction depth | Present and forward, monthly |
| Files tax returns | Yes | Yes | No, works with your CPA |
| Reviewed or audited statements for bonding | Yes | Yes, with construction depth | No |
| Owns the monthly close | Usually not | Usually not | Yes |
| Designs job cost structure against the estimate | No | Rarely | Yes |
| Forecast and what-if decisions | No | Sometimes as advisory | Yes, a 13 week forecast |
| Catches a losing job mid job | No | Rarely | Yes |
| What happens without it | Penalties and missed elections | Weaker bonding position | Accurate returns, guessed decisions |
WHEN THE PROBLEM IS TAXES AND COMPLIANCE.
If your books are current, your jobs are costed and you know where the money goes, keep a CPA for taxes and compliance. They know the filings, the elections and the entity questions. Paying a CFO to do what a CPA does well is wasted money.
It stops working when you expect the CPA to produce the numbers. They look at the year once, and they aren't in your close. So nobody looks at a job while it can still be fixed.
WHEN YOU WANT THE CPA TO KNOW CONSTRUCTION.
A CPA firm that specializes in construction understands WIP, percentage of completion revenue recognition, retention, and bonding and surety reporting. If your bonding company wants a reviewed or audited statement, that's CPA work, and a specialist does it better.
It's still mostly a look back at the year. Many of these firms offer advisory work too. Ask what the monthly work looks like and who does it.
WHEN YOU NEED SOMEONE TO PRODUCE THE MONTHLY NUMBERS.
An outsourced CFO handles the monthly close, job costing against the estimate, the forecast and the decisions that come out of them. At year end the CPA gets a clean record. The two roles do different jobs and work well together. A clean record usually makes the CPA cheaper to use.
A CFO does a different job from tax filing. A CFO doesn't replace the CPA for filings or attestation work. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something. SPM keeps your CPA in the loop and doesn't file returns.
WHERE WE COME OUT.
Keep a CPA. Taxes and compliance are required. An outsourced CFO doesn't do filings or attestation work.
Switch to a construction-focused CPA firm if the thing that hurts is bonding, reviewed statements or percentage of completion revenue recognition. A specialist is better at those.
Add an outsourced CFO if you can't say which jobs earn money or when you'll be short of cash. That's a monthly question, and a CPA isn't set up to answer it every month. For most subcontractors, the answer is the CPA for the year and a CFO for the months.
