ACCURATE BOOKS. STILL NO ANSWERS.
A general accountant produces a correct profit and loss and a filed return. Neither one can tell you which job lost money or which week you are short on cash. Construction finance needs job costing against the estimate, WIP, retention and pay application timing. If your books are accurate and your business still doesn't make sense, this is why.
General accountants do the work they're engaged to do, and they do it correctly. Construction accounting is a specialty. Revenue is recognized on percentage of completion. Costs have to be readable by job and by phase against an estimate that used different categories. 5 to 10 percent of every invoice is held as retention for months. Cash comes in 60 to 90 days after the labor was paid. A generalist codes by vendor and expense type, because that's correct for almost every other industry. The result is books that are accurate and unusable for managing work.
WHAT EACH ONE DOES.
| Capability | Generic Accountant | Construction CFO |
|---|---|---|
| Files your tax return | Yes | No, we work alongside your CPA |
| Codes costs by job and phase | Not typically, by vendor and expense type | Yes, against your estimating assemblies |
| Produces a WIP schedule | Only if specifically engaged | Monthly, reviewed before it's used |
| Maintains a cash flow forecast | No | 13 weeks, rebuilt weekly |
| Sets your overhead rate for bidding | No | Recalculated from a rolling twelve months |
| Tracks retention as a collectible asset | Recorded, not pursued | Scheduled by job with the closeout documents required |
| Benchmarks your trade | No | 48 trades by revenue band |
| Meets monthly on decisions | Usually annual or quarterly | Monthly, ending in written to dos with dates |
| Answers what should I bid this at | No | Yes, from your own production history |
Keep your CPA. The two engagements do different work. A good construction CFO makes the tax engagement easier, because the books come in clean.
THE TASKS EACH ROLE OWNS.
These are the tasks a construction company assigns to each role, taken from the full chart of who owns each task in a subcontractor. Open a role to see its tasks.
CPA, 1 task
- Review the numbers every month. Hold a tax strategy meeting with the CPA in early November, to work out what the company can do to finish the year under different scenarios.
Accounting team (AP, AR and bookkeeping), 9 tasks
- Decide what to bid and win it. Open the project in the accounting system once it's awarded.
- Manage the job. Charge equipment to projects each month.
- Pay the crews and the vendors. Code credit card transactions and invoices to the job, using the cost codes set up at the start.
- Pay the crews and the vendors. Pay the invoices when the money comes in for the project, as long as there's a current COI and W-9.
- Pay the crews and the vendors. Hold retention on the subs, and track it on the sub's pay application.
- Bill and collect. Send lien waivers with the pay application, and collect them from subs when they're paid.
- Bill and collect. Send a weekly aging report.
- Bill and collect. If the contract's payment deadline passes without payment, send a notice of nonpayment with the intent to lien.
- Close out. Close the project in the accounting system once all payments are received.
See the Accounting team (AP, AR and bookkeeping) tasks on the full chart
CFO, 5 tasks
- Set up the system. Set up the chart of accounts, which is the profit and loss statement at the business level.
- Set up the system. Choose the job cost codes, aligned with the business strategy and the work the company performs.
- Review the numbers every month. Build the 13 week cash flow forecast: week by week, with the bank account starting Monday and ending Sunday.
- Review the numbers every month. Build the CEO report: a rolling 12 months from the profit and loss statement and the balance sheet.
- Review the numbers every month. Send the WIP report to the bank or surety.
WHEN YOU NEED COMPLIANCE DONE RIGHT.
A general accountant or CPA is the right engagement for tax filing, entity structure, depreciation strategy and the annual compliance work. For most contractors that relationship should continue, whoever manages the finance work. That work is specialized in its own direction, and we don't do it.
It stops being enough for anything operational. A generalist isn't engaged to design your job cost structure, calculate your overhead rate against current volume, keep a cash flow forecast or review your WIP monthly. If you expect those from a tax engagement, that's a scope mismatch, and your accountant isn't failing you.
WHEN YOU NEED TO MANAGE THE WORK.
You need a construction CFO when the questions are operational. Which of my jobs earn? What should I bid this at? Can I fund payroll in nine weeks? How big a job can I safely take? All of those need a job cost structure built against how you estimate. No tax engagement produces one.
Here's what makes construction its own trade. Percentage of completion revenue. Cost to complete by phase. Retention tracked as a collectible asset. Certified payroll on public work lining up with the job cost record. Pay application windows that decide whether an invoice waits 30 days or 90. A generalist has no reason to know any of it.
WHERE WE COME OUT.
Use both. Keep the CPA for tax and compliance, because that work is specialized and we don't do it. Add construction finance work for everything operational, because a tax engagement was never designed to tell you which job lost money. Contractors who try to get operational answers out of a compliance engagement usually decide their accountant is underperforming. The scope just never included it.
Here's how you know you're in this spot. Your books are accurate. Your return is filed on time. And you still can't say what your last five jobs made or which week in the next quarter is tight. That means construction finance work is missing from your business.
