CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027Join the waitlist: 12 months with no subscription fee
TRADE COMPARISON · JOB COSTING

ONE CONTRACT. FOUR KINDS OF COST.

QUICK ANSWER

Mechanical, plumbing and HVAC contractors are harder to job cost because they combine work other trades keep separate. A concrete sub pours and leaves. A mechanical sub fabricates in a shop at one labor rate and installs in the field at another. Then it commissions controls with a third skill set and takes on service and warranty work after the job closes. Each has its own costs and its own risk, and all of them bill under one contract. If your cost codes are labor, material, subcontractor and equipment, you can't see the four. A job that closed thin won't tell you if the shop was slow, the field was congested, controls were underpriced or warranty work has been cutting the margin on a closed job for a year. Break out the four first. Then you can manage each one.

Target gross margin across these three trades goes from the mid twenties at the small end to the low thirties at the top, with net profit targets rising through the bands. That range is wide. You can be inside it and still lose money on two of your four cost types. So a trade average is where you start, and it won't tell you what's wrong.

Rather talk it through first? Book a 20 minute call. Nothing gets sold on this call.

Want it set up for you? Onboarding only, from $4,500 one time. Books migrated and job costing built, then your own team keeps it up.

BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished 2026-08-17Updated 2026-11-13
THE DEFINITION

WHAT IT MEANS.

Mechanical job costing is harder than most trades because one mechanical, plumbing or HVAC contract usually has four kinds of cost at once. There's prefabrication in a shop, field installation labor, controls and commissioning, and warranty or service work after substantial completion. If your cost codes put them in one bucket of labor and material, they can't tell you which of the four lost the money.

This goes unnoticed because the four cost types happen at different times. Prefab happens early, and you see its variances fast. Field labor variances come in the middle of the job, when everybody is busy. Controls and commissioning problems come at the end, when the schedule is tight and there's no time to price a change. Warranty and service cost comes in after the job is closed and reported. So it gets charged to a job nobody is watching, or to overhead, where it disappears.

So the same job can report a decent margin at closeout and lose two points over the following year, and the report that would have caught it was never produced, because the job was finished.

WHAT MAKES THESE THREE DIFFERENT

FOUR COST TYPES, ONE INVOICE, NO VISIBILITY.

01

Shop and field are two different labor rates and usually one cost code

Prefabrication is the most profitable hour a mechanical contractor sells. It's controlled, repeatable and off the critical path. Field installation is the least controlled hour, with congestion, other trades and access problems. Put both in one labor code and you get an average that fits neither. Then you can't tell whether to move more work into the shop, and that's usually the most valuable decision you can make. You need separate codes and separate rates before you can even ask the question.

02

Controls and commissioning get bid as a percentage and cost what they cost

Controls scope is often priced as a fraction of the mechanical value, because it's hard to count at bid time. Then it gets done at the end of the job, under schedule pressure, by the most expensive people on your payroll. If it isn't its own phase, the overrun spreads across the whole job and looks like general field inefficiency. Contractors who break commissioning out as a phase usually find it's been losing money for years while the installation covered it.

03

Service and warranty work reaches a job that's already closed

A closed mechanical job comes with obligations. Callbacks, warranty repairs and the service work after them all take field hours after the job was reported finished. If those hours post to overhead, the closed job keeps a margin it didn't earn, and your overhead rate rises with no explanation. If they post nowhere in particular, the service division looks unprofitable and the construction side looks better than it is. Either way, you're deciding which customers and which equipment are worth servicing without numbers.

04

Material is bought in two entirely different ways

You buy long-lead equipment with a deposit months before you install it. Pipe, fittings and duct get bought on the schedule. Those are different cash events with different risks, and with one material cost code you can't see either. A deposit paid in March for equipment installed in September is cash out and no revenue for two quarters. That's a working capital problem before it's a job cost one. It's why a growing mechanical contractor can be profitable and short of money at the same time.

THE MATH

WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE IN DOLLARS.

Test 01, can you separate shop from field? 10 minutes

Pull the labor cost on your last closed job and try to split it into fabricated and installed. If you have to estimate it, the two are pooled, and your biggest decision is being made on a feeling. This is the first change to make in your cost codes, and it pays back the fastest.

Test 02, is commissioning its own phase? 5 minutes

Look for a controls or commissioning cost code on a closed job. If the scope was bid as a percentage and coded to general field labor, you have no idea what it cost, and the overrun has been reported as installation inefficiency every time.

Test 03, where did last year's warranty hours go? 20 minutes

Take three jobs closed more than a year ago and find the hours charged against them since closeout. If the answer is none, the hours went to overhead and those jobs are reporting margins they didn't keep.

Test 04, what's out in deposits right now? 15 minutes

Total the deposits paid on long-lead equipment you haven't installed yet. That's cash you've spent on revenue you can't bill. For a growing mechanical contractor, it's often the biggest reason the bank balance and the profit and loss don't agree.

WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT

FOUR PHASES, AND ONE RULE FOR CLOSED JOBS.

Break the estimate into the four cost types, then match the cost codes to it

Shop fabrication, field installation, controls and commissioning, and service or warranty. The estimate has to break them out first, because cost codes finer than the estimate give you costs with nothing to compare against. Do it with the estimator in the room, over four one-hour sessions. Then you can read every job by phase from the first month.

Give shop and field their own burdened rates

They're different people, often on different pay scales, with different insurance exposure and very different productivity. One blended rate makes prefabrication look less profitable than it is and field work look better. That throws off every decision about where to build. Use two rates, both fully burdened, and the shop-versus-field question becomes math.

Keep a closed job open for warranty for the length of the obligation

Give each closed job one cost code that takes warranty and callback hours for as long as the warranty lasts. It costs nothing to keep up. It's the only way the margin you reported at closeout is still true a year later. It also tells you which equipment lines and which customers cause callbacks, and that's a purchasing and estimating decision worth real money.

$10.7M+
Client AR Recovered Since 2023
48
Active Trade Specializations
60 DAYS
Average Onboarding Time
PRICING

FLAT MONTHLY FEE. NO SURPRISES.

Three tiers, priced by your trailing twelve month revenue. Which one you're in depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. We don't bill by the hour, and we don't do payroll. The one-time onboarding fee is in the table.

Built for subs doing $1M to $12M. Above $12.5M we quote.

Last 12 months revenueCoreStrategicPlatinumOne-time onboarding
Under $1M$1,900$3,100$3,300$2,500
$1M to $3.5M$2,600$4,100$5,300$4,500
$3.5M to $6.5M$3,800$5,900$8,300$6,000
$6.5M to $9.5M$5,100$7,600$11,800$7,500
$9.5M to $12.5M$6,100$8,900$14,900$9,000
Above $12.5MQuotedQuotedQuotedQuoted

The onboarding fee covers migrating your books back to the start of your last taxable year and getting you fully operational in 60 days. It's billed once, with your first invoice. It's the same for all three tiers, and it moves with your revenue band. Your first month is prorated, and your monthly engagement starts on the first of the first full month.

Just want the setup? Onboarding only is the same onboarding work with no monthly service after it, one time, at the onboarding fee plus $2,000. Start a monthly engagement later and $2,000 counts toward it. It starts at $4,500, and the price for every band is on the pricing page.

The three tier columns are the whole price. Which one fits depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. No payroll. No hidden line items. The onboarding fee is right here in the table.

  • Online software only: QuickBooks, Sage, Viewpoint and similar. No VPN or hosted desktop.
  • Not in any tier: payroll, pay applications, collections on receivables.
  • Pricing valid through 2027.
Core

CFO work. Your own bookkeeper keeps doing the books.

We build your plan every month. Your team does the work.

You get the CFO work: job costing built to match the way you estimate, a 13 week cash forecast, WIP every month, and a monthly meeting that ends with decisions.

Your bookkeeper still does the books.

Strategic

Core, plus bookkeeping and bank reconciliations, plus job costing and WIP software set up and managed for you. Use your own online accounting software or we supply it, one price.

We build the plan, track it and adjust it every month.

We only work with trade subcontractors. We know what to look for, and we fix problems while they're still small. Everything in Core, plus the bookkeeping and bank reconciliations done for you, and the job costing and WIP software set up, loaded with your cost codes, and managed every month. Use your own online software, or move to ours and we pay for it.

Our team does the bookkeeping and the reconciliations. We don't do payroll.

Platinum

Strategic, plus a controller who handles payables and receivables the way an in-house controller would. You approve every payment.

We manage the money side for you, every week.

Everything in Strategic, plus our team does the controller work. We handle your bills and receivables the way an in-house controller would: we call vendors, pay the bills and keep the accounting current. We plan the cash flow first, and you approve every payment because it is your money.

Our team does the payables and receivables. We don't do payroll, pay applications or collections.

COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

The setup is the same, and the proportions differ. All three combine shop or yard work with field installation. All three include commissioning or testing at the end. All three have service obligations after closeout. Plumbing usually has less controls scope and more underground and rough-in sequencing risk. HVAC has the heaviest equipment buying and the longest lead times. Mechanical covers both and adds the most process piping. The four-phase setup works for all three. What changes by trade is which phase is biggest and which one costs the most when it's wrong.

The target range across these three trades goes from the mid twenties at the small end to the low thirties at the top of the commercial bands, and the net profit target rises through the bands with it. We publish the rows for 48 trades with their provenance. Some of those figures are measured and some come from a comparable trade, and you deserve to know which one you're comparing yourself against. The range can't tell you whether your margin comes from the shop and gets lost in commissioning. That's what this page is about.

QuickBooks can handle a four-phase setup, and plenty of mechanical contractors under about $5M use it that way successfully. What decides it is whether your estimate and your cost codes use the same setup, and whether burden reaches the job. Neither one is a software feature. What you give up is a WIP schedule, which QuickBooks won't produce on its own. On these three trades that's a real cost, because long-lead deposits and warranty obligations make over and underbilling harder to read by eye than in most trades.

Three tiers, and which one you are in depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. On Core we build your plan every month and your team does the work: job costing built against the way you estimate, a 13 week cash forecast, monthly WIP, and a monthly meeting that ends in decisions, while your bookkeeper keeps doing the books. On Strategic we build the plan, track it and adjust it every month: our team does the bookkeeping and the bank reconciliations, and the job costing and WIP software is set up and managed for you, on your own online software or ours. On Platinum we manage the money side for you every week: our team handles your bills and receivables the way an in-house controller would, and you approve every payment. We don't do payroll.

Sixty days. We migrate your books back to the start of your last taxable year and build your job costing structure from scratch, and on Strategic and Platinum we set up the job costing and WIP software too. You're fully up and working in two months. The onboarding fee is one time, the same for every tier, and set by your revenue band.
WHAT THIS TIES INTO
Josh Luebker, SPM The Construction CFO
Josh Luebker
FRACTIONAL CFO · SPM THE CONSTRUCTION CFO

Josh Luebker is a master electrician turned construction CFO, president of SPM The Construction CFO and author of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

CAN YOU SPLIT SHOP LABOR FROM FIELD LABOR?

Twenty minutes of questions about how your mechanical work gets coded, where fabrication hours land, and what your closed jobs can tell you. Nothing gets sold and nothing gets proposed. If Josh can help, you'll set a longer second call.

You don't hire a CFO because it's safe, you do it because the real risk isn't having one.
Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. No pitch or proposal. Josh asks questions to find out if he can help.

OR GET THE WIP SCHEDULE TEMPLATE. NO CALL NEEDED.