Skip to main content
JOB COSTINGCASH FLOWWIP REPORTINGFRACTIONAL CFOOVERHEAD RATEPAY APP BILLINGAR RECOVERYCONTROLQORESUBCONTRACTOR FINANCECFOSBILLING VELOCITYNET PROFITJOB COSTINGCASH FLOWWIP REPORTINGFRACTIONAL CFOOVERHEAD RATEPAY APP BILLINGAR RECOVERYCONTROLQORESUBCONTRACTOR FINANCECFOSBILLING VELOCITYNET PROFIT
THE CONSTRUCTION CFO BOOK A FREE CALL
EXCAVATION · JOB COSTING · CONSTRUCTIONCFO.NET

WHY EXCAVATION CONTRACTORS LOSE MARGIN WITHOUT KNOWING WHY.

QUICK ANSWER

Excavation production rate is cubic yards per machine hour — how much your equipment actually moved against how much your estimate assumed it would move. Every excavation bid embeds a production rate. When the job runs at a lower rate — harder material, more cycle time, longer haul, more rehandling — every hour under rate compounds across the remaining scope. Most excavation contractors track hours logged and dollars spent but never calculate the yards-per-hour variance by equipment type and soil condition.

CFOS builds production rate tracking into every excavation engagement. Actual yards per hour by equipment type are compared to estimated rates weekly — so a machine running at 70% of estimated production is identified in week 2, not at closeout.

BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished: June 2026Updated: June 2026
CY/Hour
The Right Excavation Metric
Cubic yards per machine hour by soil type and equipment — not total hours or total dollars. This is the number that connects the estimate to the field.
Soil Type
The Variable That Changes Everything
Rock, hardpan, clay, mixed, sandy loam — each has a different production rate for the same machine. An estimate built on one soil type that encounters another is wrong from day one.
Week 2
When Variance First Appears
Production rate variance on excavation is detectable within the first two weeks of digging if someone is tracking yards moved against machine hours. By week 6 it is baked in.
THE SOIL CONDITION MISMATCH
When the Material Is Not What the Estimate Assumed

An excavation contractor bids a site based on the geotechnical report showing sandy loam to 12 feet. The production rate in the estimate assumes 180 to 220 cubic yards per hour with a 200 Cat. The job starts and the operator hits dense clay at 4 feet. Dense clay with the same machine runs 90 to 120 yards per hour — half the estimated rate. On 8,000 yards of excavation, that 50% production rate reduction is 40 additional machine hours at $180 per hour — $7,200 in unrecovered cost on that phase alone, before haul is factored in.

If this is a differing site condition from what the geotechnical report represented, it is a compensable change. If it is within the range the report described, it is an estimating refinement for the next job. Either way, identifying it in week 2 determines the correct response — not in week 8 when the budget is already consumed.

THE CYCLE TIME PROBLEM
Haul Distance and Rehandling Multiply the Rate Variance

Excavation production rate is not just about how fast the machine digs — it is about the full cycle: dig, load, haul, dump, return. When haul distances are longer than estimated, cycle time extends and the effective production rate drops. When material requires rehandling — temporary stockpile before final placement, double-handling due to site logistics — every yard gets moved 1.5 times instead of once.

CFOS tracks both production rate and cycle time components — machine hours by task type, haul distances, and rehandling events. When cycle time variance is the cause of rate variance rather than material hardness, the response is different: site logistics adjustment, haul route optimization, or a change order if the site conditions differ from the contract documents.

THE EQUIPMENT UTILIZATION PROBLEM
Idle Equipment on a Running Budget

Excavation equipment costs money whether it is digging or waiting. An excavator waiting for trucks, a dozer staged while another machine clears, a compactor on site three days before it is needed — every idle hour is overhead the estimate did not plan for. On a $600,000 excavation job with three machines and 20% idle time, that is $24,000 in unrecovered equipment cost before any production rate variance is factored in.

CFOS tracks equipment utilization separately from production rate — hours running versus hours on site. When utilization drops below 75% on a machine, the trigger fires: sequence adjustment, dispatch change, or a conversation with the GC about site access delays that may support a delay claim.

01
TRACK YARDS MOVED BY EQUIPMENT TYPE AND SOIL CONDITION
Every day, record cubic yards excavated by machine type and soil condition encountered. Calculate actual yards per hour. Compare to the estimated rate for that equipment and material type. A machine at 70% of estimated production rate has a problem — material, cycle time, or utilization — that is identifiable and addressable in the same week.
02
CAPTURE CYCLE TIME COMPONENTS SEPARATELY
Log machine hours by task: dig and load, haul, dump and return, idle. When cycle time variance is driving rate variance, the cause is haul distance or site logistics — not machine capability or soil hardness. The correct response is different and requires different documentation.
03
DOCUMENT CHANGED SOIL CONDITIONS WITHIN 48 HOURS
When material encountered differs materially from the geotechnical report — harder, wetter, more contaminated — document the condition the day it is encountered. Written notice to the GC within 48 hours. Change order submitted in the same billing period. See grading changed conditions process for the full documentation standard.
04
WEEKLY EQUIPMENT UTILIZATION REVIEW
Every week, total hours on site versus hours running per machine. When utilization drops below 75%, identify the cause — site access, sequencing, waiting on other trades — and determine whether it supports a delay claim or requires internal sequence adjustment.
$2.1M+
Client AR Recovered Since 2023
18
Active Trade Specializations
60 DAYS
Average Onboarding Time
PRICING

FLAT MONTHLY FEE. NO SURPRISES.

Two tiers based on trailing 12-month revenue. No hourly billing. No payroll. No add-ons.

RevenueCore FinancialExecutive Financial
Under $1M$1,900/mo$2,900/mo
$1M–$3M$2,600/mo$3,600/mo
$4M–$6M$3,800/mo$5,500/mo
$7M–$9M$5,100/mo$6,900/mo
$10M–$12M$6,100/mo$8,500/mo
$13M+QuotedQuoted
What's Included →
COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

Production rate estimates for excavation work are built on historical actuals — yards per hour by machine type, soil condition, and cycle time components — from similar previous jobs. Industry references like RS Means provide validation benchmarks but should be calibrated to your own equipment and crew performance. An excavation contractor with 3+ years of production rate tracking by soil type has a significant estimating advantage over one using generic tables.
Four common causes: harder material than the geotechnical report indicated, longer haul distances than planned, more rehandling than estimated, and equipment idle time from site logistics or access delays. Each cause has a different response — material hardness may be a compensable changed condition, haul and rehandling variance may be an estimating refinement, and idle time from GC-caused delays may support a delay claim.
CFOS serves commercial subcontractors doing $1M to $12M. Core Financial starts at $1,900 per month. Executive Financial starts at $2,900 per month. Onboarding takes 60 days.
Core Financial includes ControlQore setup, job costing aligned to your estimates, full-service bookkeeping, and bank reconciliations. Executive Financial adds monthly CFO advisory meetings, controllership, and strategic accountability. No payroll. No scope gaps.
Josh Luebker
Josh Luebker
Fractional CFO · The Construction CFO

Former commercial construction PM and master electrician. 150+ projects, $300M+ in volume. Now fractional CFO for commercial subcontractors doing $1M–$12M through Sulphur Prairie Management. About Josh →  |  LinkedIn →  |  CONTROL Book →

RELATED
Trade OS
Excavation Operating System
The full CFOS architecture for excavation contractors — equipment cost, production tracking, and billing
CFOS Module
Job Profitability System
The CFOS module that tracks production rates by equipment type against the estimate weekly
Related
Grading Cut/Fill Variance
How to document changed soil conditions and recover compensation on grading and excavation work
CFOS SYSTEM CONNECTIONS
SYSTEM SPINE
Run on CFOSJob Profitability SystemExcavation OS
RELATED
Grading Changed ConditionsCivil Equipment UtilizationLabor Productivity
PROOF
Civil MCA Case StudyGrading Equipment Case StudyFractional CFO Services

DO YOU KNOW YOUR ACTUAL YARDS
PER HOUR BY EQUIPMENT TYPE?

30 minutes. We will calculate your actual production rate on a current job and compare it to your estimate before we talk about anything else.

BOOK A FREE DIAGNOSTIC CALL →

OR SEE YOUR NUMBERS FIRST → FREE CEO REPORT TOOL
THE CONSTRUCTION CFO
Run on CFOS Job Profitability Fractional CFO Schedule a Call CONTROL Book
© 2026 SULPHUR PRAIRIE MANAGEMENT · SULPHUR ROCK, AR
0
Josh Luebker, The Construction CFO
JOSH LUEBKER
FOUNDER & CFO

Master electrician and former project manager, 150+ projects and $2.1B+ in commercial work. Now runs the numbers for subcontractors instead of standing on the job site.

LinkedIn About
Stewart Bohrer, The Construction CFO
STEWART BOHRER
VP OF OPERATIONS

Keeps the system running day to day: job costing, WIP, monthly financial reviews, and the follow-through between calls. Josh handles onboarding.

LinkedIn About
LinkedIn YouTube About Run on CFOS