CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027Join the waitlist: 12 months with no subscription fee
ESTIMATING, BID STRATEGY

WINNING TOO MANY BIDS IS A MARGIN PROBLEM.

QUICK ANSWER

A healthy bid win rate for a commercial subcontractor on competitive work is 20 to 35%. A win rate above 40% is a warning sign. If you're winning more than one in three competitive bids, you're probably bidding below market. You're winning on price, and a cheap price means thin margins. The growth is producing losses nobody has recognized yet.

Commercial construction is competitive bidding, so the market sets the price and your number is either inside it or below it. If you win more than a third of what you pursue, you're consistently the low number. There are only two explanations. Either you're cheap on purpose and you know your cost, or your cost model is wrong and you don't know it. The second is far more common. The usual cause is an old overhead rate in the bid model that no longer covers what the office costs to operate.

Rather talk it through first? Book a 20 minute call. Nothing gets sold on this call.

Want Josh to check your own numbers? Financial Health Snapshot, $1,500 one time. Your last 12 months read against your trade's benchmarks, with a 60 minute readout.

BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished 2026-08-06Updated 2026-11-14
THE DEFINITION

WHAT IT MEANS.

A bid win rate is the share of the competitive bids you submit that you're awarded, and above 35% it's telling you your price is below the market.

The win rate is the cheapest test in the business, because you already own the data. Two causes account for most high win rates. One is an overhead rate that hasn't been rebuilt from real financials. The other is cost categories missing from the estimate entirely. Both give you a bid that looks competitive because it's incomplete.

WHAT OVERPRICED WIN RATES LOOK LIKE BY TRADE

SAME SYMPTOM, DIFFERENT MISSING COST.

01

Concrete, winning on missed costs

Concrete subs winning 50% or more of their bids are usually missing real costs: small tools, pump time, finishing labor at overtime and washout fees. The bid looks lean because the estimate is incomplete. The 30% to 40% profit they think they're making comes in at 3% to 5% once the missed costs are counted.

02

Civil, the equipment subsidy

Civil contractors with high win rates are often subsidizing bids with unpriced equipment. Either the machines are billed to jobs at rates below true cost basis, or the idle time goes into overhead and nobody prices it. Every win at a subsidized rate adds to the loss. The market is accepting a donation.

03

Electrical, the work type blind spot

Electrical subs commonly win everything in one work type and lose everything in another. They take rough-in at a loss and lose trim bids they would have profited on, because both use the same blended markup. A lopsided win rate by work type tells you the cost model is wrong in opposite directions at the same time.

04

SWPPP and service trades, the utilization trap

T&M and service trades win too much when their rates are built on busy month math. A rate that pencils at 90% utilization loses money at the 60% the year averages out to. A high win rate, a full schedule and an empty bank account together mean the rate sheet ignores utilization.

THE MATH

WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE IN DOLLARS.

The win rate bands

Below 15% means you're bidding too high or pursuing the wrong market. 20% to 35% is the healthy competitive range. 35% to 50% is the watch zone where the overhead rate needs checking, and above 50% you're almost certainly bidding below cost.

41% down to 28%, with margin up

After one client corrected their overhead rate and repriced, win rate fell from 41% to 28%, squarely into the healthy band, while gross margin rose from 19% to 26%. The bids they stopped winning were the ones priced below cost. Losing those was the profit.

Negative 1% to 11% net before taxes

A $6.7M civil contractor was bidding 10% overhead against a real 30%, which means losing 1% on every job before mobilization. Once overhead came down to 18% and every bid used that rate with competitive profit on top, the same bid volume produced 11% net before taxes. The market and the competitors hadn't changed.

$203K in week one

A verified concrete client at $4.9M was bidding off a 5% book overhead against a real number of 12%, winning constantly and netting 3.3% before taxes. The correction started with collecting $203K of overdue AR in week one, then repricing the forward work. The next year brought $1.3M less revenue, more profit, and $130K in first ever profit sharing.

HOW SPM FIXES IT

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE RATE GETS CORRECTED.

Calculate the real overhead rate from expense data, then compare it to the bid

First, divide total annual overhead by annual revenue, using real expense data. Second, compare that figure to what's in the estimates today. Most growing subcontractors find the estimate uses 10 to 12% while the real rate is 18 to 24%. That difference is the margin you lose on every job.

Reprice forward work and accept the lower win rate

Some of the work stops coming in, and that's the goal. Work won at prices that don't cover overhead and profit is worse than work you never won. A subcontractor who wins 22% of competitive bids at correct margin makes more money than one who wins 55% at margin that doesn't cover the office.

Split the win rate by work type

A blended win rate won't show you the problem. If you win nearly everything in one work type and lose nearly everything in another, the cost model is wrong in both directions, and the blended markup covers it up. Split the win rate by work type and you see which part of the estimate is off.

Watch the margin on the work you win

The win rate tells you to go look. The gross margin on the jobs you won tells you what's wrong. Track both together and you know whether the last repricing worked.

$10.7M+
Client AR Recovered Since 2023
48
Active Trade Specializations
60 DAYS
Average Onboarding Time
PRICING

FLAT MONTHLY FEE. NO SURPRISES.

Three tiers, priced by your trailing twelve month revenue. Which one you're in depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. We don't bill by the hour, and we don't do payroll. The one-time onboarding fee is in the table.

Built for subs doing $1M to $12M. Above $12.5M we quote.

Last 12 months revenueCoreStrategicPlatinumOne-time onboarding
Under $1M$1,900$3,100$3,300$2,500
$1M to $3.5M$2,600$4,100$5,300$4,500
$3.5M to $6.5M$3,800$5,900$8,300$6,000
$6.5M to $9.5M$5,100$7,600$11,800$7,500
$9.5M to $12.5M$6,100$8,900$14,900$9,000
Above $12.5MQuotedQuotedQuotedQuoted

The onboarding fee covers migrating your books back to the start of your last taxable year and getting you fully operational in 60 days. It's billed once, with your first invoice. It's the same for all three tiers, and it moves with your revenue band. Your first month is prorated, and your monthly engagement starts on the first of the first full month.

Just want the setup? Onboarding only is the same onboarding work with no monthly service after it, one time, at the onboarding fee plus $2,000. Start a monthly engagement later and $2,000 counts toward it. It starts at $4,500, and the price for every band is on the pricing page.

The three tier columns are the whole price. Which one fits depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. No payroll. No hidden line items. The onboarding fee is right here in the table.

  • Online software only: QuickBooks, Sage, Viewpoint and similar. No VPN or hosted desktop.
  • Not in any tier: payroll, pay applications, collections on receivables.
  • Pricing valid through 2027.
Core

CFO work. Your own bookkeeper keeps doing the books.

We build your plan every month. Your team does the work.

You get the CFO work: job costing built to match the way you estimate, a 13 week cash forecast, WIP every month, and a monthly meeting that ends with decisions.

Your bookkeeper still does the books.

Strategic

Core, plus bookkeeping and bank reconciliations, plus job costing and WIP software set up and managed for you. Use your own online accounting software or we supply it, one price.

We build the plan, track it and adjust it every month.

We only work with trade subcontractors. We know what to look for, and we fix problems while they're still small. Everything in Core, plus the bookkeeping and bank reconciliations done for you, and the job costing and WIP software set up, loaded with your cost codes, and managed every month. Use your own online software, or move to ours and we pay for it.

Our team does the bookkeeping and the reconciliations. We don't do payroll.

Platinum

Strategic, plus a controller who handles payables and receivables the way an in-house controller would. You approve every payment.

We manage the money side for you, every week.

Everything in Strategic, plus our team does the controller work. We handle your bills and receivables the way an in-house controller would: we call vendors, pay the bills and keep the accounting current. We plan the cash flow first, and you approve every payment because it is your money.

Our team does the payables and receivables. We don't do payroll, pay applications or collections.

COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

Yes, on negotiated work with long term GC relationships where your track record earns you a preferred position. On open competitive bids where several subcontractors submit prices, efficiency gives you a lower cost to execute, and your bid price stays at market. An efficient subcontractor should still be winning 20 to 35% of competitive bids. Winning 60% means you're the lowest price every time.

Two steps. First, calculate the real overhead rate from expense data, meaning total annual overhead divided by annual revenue. Second, compare it to what's in the estimates. Most growing subcontractors find the estimate uses 10 to 12% and the real rate is 18 to 24%. That difference is the margin that disappears on every job without anybody noticing until year end.

Some of it, which is the point. Work won at prices that don't cover overhead and profit is worse than not winning that work. A subcontractor who wins 22% of competitive bids at correct margin makes more money than one who wins 55% at margin that doesn't cover overhead. The first one has a profitable business and the second one has a revenue number and a cash problem.

GC relationships built entirely on being the cheapest bid are a permanent discount. Experienced GCs keep subs they trust at competitive but real prices, because blown schedules and failed subs cost them far more than a few percent on the bid. When clients reprice, they typically lose the GCs who only ever wanted the donation and keep the ones worth keeping. One client's repriced book of work came with $65K in bonuses and a paid off line of credit, and the GCs stayed.

20 to 35% on competitively bid work is the healthy band. Below 20% you're either overpriced for your market or bidding the wrong work, and both are worth diagnosing. Above 35% sustained, you're almost certainly the cheapest, and the question is whether you're cheap on purpose with full cost knowledge or cheap by accident through a broken overhead rate. Negotiated and relationship work is higher legitimately. The number to watch is the margin on the work you win.
WHAT THIS TIES INTO
Josh Luebker, SPM The Construction CFO
Josh Luebker
FRACTIONAL CFO · SPM THE CONSTRUCTION CFO

Josh Luebker is a master electrician turned construction CFO, president of SPM The Construction CFO and author of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

HOW MANY OF YOUR LAST TEN BIDS DID YOU WIN?

Josh spends twenty minutes asking about your win rate, your estimate build-up, and what the jobs look like once they close out. He won't sell you anything and no proposal follows. If he can help, you'll set a longer call.

You don't hire a CFO because it's safe, you do it because the real risk isn't having one.
Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. No pitch or proposal. Josh asks questions to find out if he can help.

OR GET THE EQUIPMENT COST BASIS CALCULATOR. NO CALL NEEDED.