CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027Join the waitlist: 12 months with no subscription fee
EQUIPMENT DECISIONS

BUY, RENT, OR LEASE. HERE'S THE ANALYSIS MOST CONTRACTORS SKIP.

QUICK ANSWER

The equipment buy versus rent decision depends on utilization rate. Above 60% billable utilization, buying typically wins over 5 years. Below 40%, renting is almost always cheaper once you count depreciation, insurance, maintenance, financing, and idle time.

Utilization decides it, and it's the one figure that usually gets skipped. A machine that works 150 days a year covers its own ownership cost. The same machine at 60 days a year is a payment you make whether it works or not. The payment doesn't stop when the schedule slows down. Count the billable days first. Then price all three options against that day count. Buy a machine you use half as often as you assumed, and a good year leaves you with a fleet you can't pay for.

Rather talk it through first? Book a 20 minute call. Nothing gets sold on this call.

Want Josh to check your own numbers? Financial Health Snapshot, $1,500 one time. Your last 12 months read against your trade's benchmarks, with a 60 minute readout.

BY JOSH LUEBKERPublished 2026-08-06Updated 2026-11-14
THE DEFINITION

WHAT IT MEANS.

An internal equipment rate is the cost per hour or day assigned to owned equipment when it works a job.

Renting costs the most per day and commits you to nothing. Buying costs the least per day at high utilization, and you owe the payment either way. Leasing is between them. You give up some of the ownership upside for a smaller commitment. The number of billable days the machine will work decides which one wins, so count that first.

WHAT WE SEE IN THIS BUSINESS

WHY THE EQUIPMENT CALL GOES WRONG.

01

They buy without modeling utilization

The decision is usually emotional. Somebody says we're always renting this machine, might as well own it, and the purchase order goes out that same week. The math only works if the machine is on billable jobs often enough to cover the ownership cost. In most cases nobody counted the days it would work before the money was spent.

02

Equipment costs get booked to overhead

Without an internal equipment rate, depreciation, loan payments and maintenance costs all go into overhead. The jobs that used the machine aren't charged for it, so they look more profitable than they are. The cost ends up in overhead, and nobody can trace it back to a single job.

03

The down payment takes cash at the worst time

A large new contract is often what triggers an equipment purchase. That's the same time mobilization is about to take your cash. A $60K to $100K down payment on a new machine, on top of mobilization costs for the new job, can create a cash crisis. The contract that justified the machine is the reason you can't afford it that month.

THE MATH

WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE IN DOLLARS.

A $200K excavator, buy against rent over 5 years

Year one on the buy is $40K down plus $36K in payments, so $76K goes out. Over 5 years the buy totals roughly $268K, with a residual of about $80K still in the machine. Renting the same excavator at 150 days a year totals roughly $675K over those same 5 years. The buy wins by about $487K, and all of that comes from the 150 days.

The utilization test

Above 60 percent billable utilization, buying typically wins over 5 years. Below 40 percent, renting is almost always cheaper once you count depreciation, insurance, maintenance, financing, and idle time. Between those two numbers, the internal equipment rate decides it. A few days a year can move the answer either way.

HOW SPM FIXES IT

HOW TO CALCULATE THE NUMBERS.

The utilization test

First, count the billable days the machine will work in a year. Take them from your own schedule and backlog. Ownership cost per day is total cost divided by days worked, so that day count decides everything after it. Once you have the days, you can price buying, renting and leasing against the same number.

Build the internal equipment rate

Set a daily or hourly charge per machine that covers depreciation, a maintenance reserve, insurance, and financing. When the machine works a job, that job gets charged at the rate. SPM builds this into ControlQore so equipment costs post to jobs automatically and the overhead allocation stays accurate.

Model the cash impact

A financed purchase takes 10 to 20 percent down plus monthly payments. For most commercial equipment the down payment is $50K to $150K, and the cash leaves right away. That figure goes into the cash forecast next to the mobilization on the job that triggered the purchase, so you see both in the same week. If you can't cover both that week, rent this machine.

$10.7M+
Client AR Recovered Since 2023
48
Active Trade Specializations
60 DAYS
Average Onboarding Time
PRICING

FLAT MONTHLY FEE. NO SURPRISES.

Three tiers, priced by your trailing twelve month revenue. Which one you're in depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. We don't bill by the hour, and we don't do payroll. The one-time onboarding fee is in the table.

Built for subs doing $1M to $12M. Above $12.5M we quote.

Last 12 months revenueCoreStrategicPlatinumOne-time onboarding
Under $1M$1,900$3,100$3,300$2,500
$1M to $3.5M$2,600$4,100$5,300$4,500
$3.5M to $6.5M$3,800$5,900$8,300$6,000
$6.5M to $9.5M$5,100$7,600$11,800$7,500
$9.5M to $12.5M$6,100$8,900$14,900$9,000
Above $12.5MQuotedQuotedQuotedQuoted

The onboarding fee covers migrating your books back to the start of your last taxable year and getting you fully operational in 60 days. It's billed once, with your first invoice. It's the same for all three tiers, and it moves with your revenue band. Your first month is prorated, and your monthly engagement starts on the first of the first full month.

Just want the setup? Onboarding only is the same onboarding work with no monthly service after it, one time, at the onboarding fee plus $2,000. Start a monthly engagement later and $2,000 counts toward it. It starts at $4,500, and the price for every band is on the pricing page.

The three tier columns are the whole price. Which one fits depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. No payroll. No hidden line items. The onboarding fee is right here in the table.

  • Online software only: QuickBooks, Sage, Viewpoint and similar. No VPN or hosted desktop.
  • Not in any tier: payroll, pay applications, collections on receivables.
  • Pricing valid through 2027.
Core

CFO work. Your own bookkeeper keeps doing the books.

We build your plan every month. Your team does the work.

You get the CFO work: job costing built to match the way you estimate, a 13 week cash forecast, WIP every month, and a monthly meeting that ends with decisions.

Your bookkeeper still does the books.

Strategic

Core, plus bookkeeping and bank reconciliations, plus job costing and WIP software set up and managed for you. Use your own online accounting software or we supply it, one price.

We build the plan, track it and adjust it every month.

We only work with trade subcontractors. We know what to look for, and we fix problems while they're still small. Everything in Core, plus the bookkeeping and bank reconciliations done for you, and the job costing and WIP software set up, loaded with your cost codes, and managed every month. Use your own online software, or move to ours and we pay for it.

Our team does the bookkeeping and the reconciliations. We don't do payroll.

Platinum

Strategic, plus a controller who handles payables and receivables the way an in-house controller would. You approve every payment.

We manage the money side for you, every week.

Everything in Strategic, plus our team does the controller work. We handle your bills and receivables the way an in-house controller would: we call vendors, pay the bills and keep the accounting current. We plan the cash flow first, and you approve every payment because it is your money.

Our team does the payables and receivables. We don't do payroll, pay applications or collections.

COMMON QUESTIONS

FREQUENTLY ASKED.

It depends on utilization rate. If the equipment will be used 60 percent or more of the time on billable jobs, buying typically wins over 5 years. Below 40 percent utilization, renting is almost always cheaper when you factor in depreciation, insurance, maintenance, financing, and idle time.

An internal equipment rate is the cost per hour or day assigned to owned equipment when it works a job. It covers depreciation, a maintenance reserve, insurance, and financing. Without it, equipment costs go into overhead and job margins look better than the jobs earned.

A financed equipment purchase requires 10 to 20 percent down plus monthly payments. The down payment is an immediate cash event, $50K to $150K for most commercial equipment. If the machine isn't working enough billable days to offset ownership costs, it costs you both cash and margin.

Set an internal equipment rate, a daily or hourly charge per machine. When the equipment works a job, that job gets charged at the rate. SPM builds this into ControlQore so equipment costs post to jobs automatically and the overhead allocation stays accurate.

Three tiers, and which one you are in depends on how much of the work you want off your desk. On Core we build your plan every month and your team does the work: job costing built against the way you estimate, a 13 week cash forecast, monthly WIP, and a monthly meeting that ends in decisions, while your bookkeeper keeps doing the books. On Strategic we build the plan, track it and adjust it every month: our team does the bookkeeping and the bank reconciliations, and the job costing and WIP software is set up and managed for you, on your own online software or ours. On Platinum we manage the money side for you every week: our team handles your bills and receivables the way an in-house controller would, and you approve every payment. We don't do payroll.
WHAT THIS TIES INTO
Josh Luebker, SPM The Construction CFO
Josh Luebker
FRACTIONAL CFO · SPM THE CONSTRUCTION CFO

Josh Luebker is a master electrician turned construction CFO, president of SPM The Construction CFO and author of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

SHOULD THAT MACHINE BE BOUGHT, RENTED, OR LEASED?

The twenty minutes go to questions about the machine you're looking at, the days you'd put on it, and what your schedule holds. Josh isn't selling anything and he won't propose anything. If he can help, you'll set a longer call.

You don't hire a CFO because it's safe, you do it because the real risk isn't having one.
Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. No pitch or proposal. Josh asks questions to find out if he can help.

OR GET THE WIP SCHEDULE TEMPLATE. NO CALL NEEDED.